Children of the Underground
Women's Shelters Arm of Underground
Rita Mazzie entered the underground through the doors of a women's shelter.
But does that mean America's growing network of domestic violence shelters has become an arm of the underground?
"Actually, yes," says one lawyer who has extensive underground contacts and asked not to be identified. "There is a federally funded underground in this country - women's shelters. A woman and children will go in, she'll say she's been abused, and if they think she's being stalked, they'll call up another shelter and send her there. And that's often the start of a life on the run."
Sometimes, shelter officials go a step further, hooking women up with networks that have "safe houses" and can provide false identity papers, like the one run by Atlanta's Faye Yager, who acknowledges she gets many of her referrals from shelters.
Marty Friday, director of the Pittsburgh Women's Center and Shelter, says she's heard of Faye Yager - but doesn't refer women to her.
"This might be splitting hairs, but for the most part shelters will tell people what their options are, and let people choose for themselves," Friday says.
"When someone is truly fleeing for her life, or for her children, the moral issues get very complicated," says Friday.
Some shelters have been the target of lawsuits by fathers, and some shelter employees have been charged in abduction cases with obstruction of justice.
Most women's shelters work closely with police, but when they get involved in helping a mother flee, it can put a strain on their relationships with law enforcement officials.
A San Francisco shelter was raided several years ago by police, who charged that the shelter's director was harboring fugitives at the request of organized underground leaders. The entire shelter's staff was replaced with new employees - strict instructions to check custody orders carefully.
Domestic violence organizations counter by saying that ineffective law enforcement - and judges who don't believe claims of abuse - are driving women underground.
"Until the courts start to look at the evidence that is presented about the safety of children, mothers are going to be forced to take actions that are not legal," says Rita Smith, executive director of the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence.
And many shelters, concerned primarily with protecting a woman and her children, will continue to look the other way when it comes to issues of custody.
"The less we know, the more we can protect ourselves," says one shelter official who asked not to be identified. "Our job is, first and foremost, to protect our clients from harm. And to do that, we also need to protect ourselves from liability."
Article Sections
- Children of the Underground
- Network Symptom of Social Ills, Faulty Courts
- Secret Network Hides Families on the Run
- Bending the Law to Defend the Children
- A Passion to Protect
- Here's How to Disappear Into Faye's Underground
- Two Families Endlessly Await Child's Return
- Where to Turn When a Child is Missing
- Why Would You Want to Take a Baby from Me
- The Cost of Living on the Run: No Home, No Friends, Just Fear
- These Children Can't Take it Any Longer
- Women's Shelters Arm of Underground
Mackenzie Carpenter
-
Mackenzie Carpenter is a staff writer for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, where she has worked since 1990. She has written numerous prize-winning series on such diverse issues as liver transplant allocation; child care in the United States; the education of gifted children; domestic violence, and divorce and custody issues. Her 1997 series, "Children of the Underground," dealt with mothers who hide their children in violation of custody orders. It won a number of national, state and local awards and was republished in international newspapers and magazines, including Corriere Della Serra and Elle. Ms. Carpenter began her career as an assistant to Washington D.C. political correspondents Martin Agronsky and Paul Duke, moving on to become a field producer for public television in Washington, D.C. and, later, as host and producer of a program on politics for the Pennsylvania Public Television Network. She also worked as a reporter for the Journal-Inquirer in Manchester, CT, and United Press International's state capitol bureau in Harrisburg. She was raised in Princeton, N.J. and Tokyo and received a bachelor's degree in English from Trinity College in Hartford, CT in 1976 and a master's degree in studies in law from Yale Law School in 1987.
Allen Detrich
-
Allen Detrich is a photographer at the Pittsburg Post-Gazette.
Request Publications
-

Tragedies & Journalists
A 40-page guide to help journalists, photojournalists and editors report on violence while protecting both victims and themselves.
-

Covering Children & Trauma
When children are victims of violence, journalists have a responsibility to report the truth with compassion and sensitivity.
