AEJMC Panel: Covering Victims of Crime
International Conference & Summit on Violence, Abuse & Trauma
Panel: Clinical Lessons from Journalists
Conversation with Aluf Benn
Victims and the media is an intensive study of the interpersonal and psychological effects of trauma on journalists and the people they interview. Special interest is given to identifying the symptoms of post-traumatic-stress-disorder and its impact upon journalists and victims of disasters and other horrific events. The course analyzes the cultural production of violent images in print, broadcast, photographic and entertainment media.
Victims and the Media Program at Michigan State University, Department of Journalism.
Dart Center for Journalism and Trauma at the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism.
Center for People and the Media at the University of Central Oklahoma, Department of Mass Communication.
Frank Ochberg, M.D. Articles on P.T.S.D. (See, for instance, Gift from Within.)
The student will complete two topical papers on a selected issue from the required texts for the course. The topical papers will be 3-5 pages in length, double-spaced using 12-point font. Three additional academic research sources are required for these topical papers. The topics from which these papers will be written are: Glassner (1999), Simpson and Cote’ (2006), Sontag (2003) and (2001), and Benedict (1992). Simpson and Cote’ (2006) will be read and used for developing a conceptual framework for analyzing the cultural practices of reporting, interviewing and representing victims. One of the three topical papers will be further developed into your final 10 page research paper. An acceptable style manual such as APA or MLA is a requirement for the topical papers. Documentary films and other analytical media (not movies) shown in the class or that you have critically viewed may be used as a source. Wikipedia is not an acceptable secondary source.
The student will complete a 10-page paper, which further develops one of the topical papers of their choosing. This research paper will be the culminating project in the course. The paper must have a minimum of 7 academic/primary sources. Your research should make some significant contribution to the victims and the media course of study.
Ms. Edna Buchanan was the first woman to work as a crime beat reporter at the Miama Herald for over 20 years. Her autobiographical book: The Corpse Had a Familiar Face is often cited for the light it sheds upon victims of crime and natural disaster. You will write a three to five page reaction paper to Buchanan’s book reflecting upon what insights she makes on covering victims on the newsbeat.
The papers written for the course can be theoretical or applied analyses. For instance, a theoretical paper might look at how the media creates fear such as in Glassner’s book The Culture of Fear. Another topic such as from Sontag (2003) concerns the oversaturation of horrific images in a 24 hour news cycle culture which has left us with the inability to feel empathy for others. Your arguments should contain theoretical premises and examples backed up with theory. An applied study might critique the devastating effects of Hurricane Katrina and the people it affected and traumatized using Cote and Simpson’s stages of a disaster, post-traumatic effects and a critique of the photographs of the victims of Katrina. Another applied type study might concern how the media caused a feeding frenzy after Columbine in the inept efforts to explain this event. (See my article on Hate Crime Reporting in your course packet for an example of an applied study of the Matthew Shepard hate crime and the media.)
Several Victims and the Media students have published their research projects in the course. The Western Journal of Social Science is a campus based, refereed, scholarly journal, especially designed for undergraduate students. The New Plains Review housed in the Dept. of English solicits scholarly manuscripts for publication. Student funded research projects may be available through the Office of Graduate Studies. A proposed book of exemplary undergraduate research from this class may be under consideration providing there is quality research papers generated from the course.
Since this is a seminar class that entails working together to have high quality discussion, attendance is required. The instructor will allow three excused absences during the semester. After three, your final grade will be dropped one letter. Two more will constitute another one letter grade drop. Six absences will be considered a failure to participate in the seminar warranting a grade of “F”. Students should complete all reading assignments and be on time for class.
A top ranked paper will be selected for a cash award in the fall for The Joe Hight Fellowship award. Conference travel money is available for students interested in presenting at an academic conference.
The subject matter of this course will be taught in a student-centered discussion format equivalent to an upper-level (4000-5000) undergraduate or graduate seminar. It is imperative that the student is on time and is completing the required readings. Moreover, you will be expected to engage in critical discussion, analysis, and application of the readings, films, and other materials presented in the class. Group presentation of selected chapters is required.
Students will have ample time to complete their topical research projects and research paper. One half letter grade will be taken off for each day an assignment is late. If a student misses their group presentation one letter grade will be taken from their final course grade.
The two required topical research papers are worth 20% each of your course grade.
A reaction paper of 3-5 pages of what you learned about reporting about victims from the Edna Buchanan book, The Corpse Had a Familiar Face (1991) is required. This paper will be worth 20% of the final course grade.
The final research project is worth 40% of your course grade.
Attendance, including being on time for class, and participating in all of the assignments such as watching the videos, hearing your classmates and professor present and discuss ideas is expected.
Anyone who publishes his or her research paper in the class will automatically receive a grade of “A”.
Plagiarism: Plagiarism or adopting others work as your own will not be tolerated in this course. The student will immediately fail the assignment, possibly risk failing the course, and be reported to the Dean of Student Affairs.
You must learn how to cite research using the APA or MLA Style manual. These research writing guides are available in Chambers Library and on-line.
59 or below=F
Class time is taken seriously for learning a difficult terrain of new material. It is expected that all cell phones remain off in the course. That means no text messaging during class. Polite behavior by all is conducive to a civil and dynamic classroom. Please refrain from side conversations during the films and class discussion.
Week One: Reading: Culture of Fear (1999). Cote and Simpson will assign particular chapters. Discussion groups over Glassner assigned.
Week Two: Video: Bowling for Columbine (2001) by Michael Moore.
Week Three: Critical viewing: Violence an American Tradition (1995). How has American journalistic culture made hero’s out of violent people?
Week Four: Paper I Due. Discuss results of paper. Read: The Corpse Had a Familiar Face (1991). Discussion groups over selected Buchanan cases. Read Simpson and Cote’ (2006) on journalist as victim and approaching victims of violence.
Week Five: What does it mean to report on and to encounter victims?
Week Six: What does it mean to be a victim? Tips for Interviewing Victims. Role Playing of Victims Interviews. Read Interviewing Victims in Cote and Simpson video by Dr. Frank Ochberg on Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and victims of violence. Guest Speaker: Mr. Mark Brenneman. Reaction Paper Due.
Week Seven: Video Covering Columbine. Discuss how the media reported and interviewed Columbine high school students. Read Simpson ad Cote’ (2006) on Columbine.
Week Eight: Covering Hate Crimes. Assigned Readings.
Week Nine: Read: Virgin or Vamp: How the Press Covers Sex Crimes. Discussion groups assigned over each of the cases.
Week Ten: Spring Break March 20-23
Week Eleven : Read article by Catherine McKinney on incest survivors in Cote and Simpson. Topical Paper II Due.
Week Twelve: Read Sontag On Photography (1977). Discuss
Week Thirteen: Read Sontag Regarding the Pain of Others (2003).
Week Fourteen: Analysis of Images of War and other horrific events
Week Fifteen: Final expanded 10 page research paper due the week before finals week.
Week Sixteen: Finish course
Note: Topics may take longer than expected to complete. Times, dates, and topics on the syllabus are subject to change. All required writing assignments must be completed in order to pass the course.
You must complete all writing assignments to pass the course. The papers are spaced apart with ample time for the student to conduct his/her research contributions.
Your contributions help the Dart Center nurture informed, innovative and ethical news reporting on violence, conflict and tragedy worldwide.
The Dart Center is a project of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism.