The Hardest Case for Mercy

Read the piece

This tour de force in feature writing takes readers inside the effort to spare the Parkland school shooter from the death penalty.

Judges said the piece sets "the highest bar for what journalism can achieve.” They commended the project for highlighting “how trauma rippled outward, touching victims’ families, the defense team, and the entire community” in the “long, messy, and painful aftermath of the Parkland school shooting.” They applauded the piece for its “unflinching honesty” and for “mapping the roots and veins of intergenerational trauma” “without downplaying Nikolas Cruz’s guilt, showing empathy for the tragic events that shaped his mental state, but never letting the reader forget the horrific consequences of his actions.” They praised writer Joe Sexton for “presenting the full weight of the story with nuance, trusting the reader to grapple with its moral complexity,” and for “reminding journalists that before they can explain loss, they must first understand what people have to lose.”

Originally published by The Marshall Project.